What the Latest PV Tech Report Actually Tells Us
According to a recent PV Tech report, the financial health of Chinese and Indian solar PV manufacturers is moving in opposite directions.
The report, produced in collaboration with PV Tech Research, highlights that major Chinese manufacturers, including JinkoSolar, JA Solar, LONGi and Trina Solar, continue to face financial pressure following years of declining PV supply chain prices and intense market competition.
Meanwhile, Indian solar manufacturers have strengthened their financial positions, benefiting from booming domestic demand, the Approved List of Models and Manufacturers (ALMM) policy introduced in 2024, and access to higher-priced US markets.
The report uses the Altman Z-Score, a financial indicator designed to assess a company's financial health and potential bankruptcy risk, to illustrate this difference.
But there is one important question that should not be overlooked:
Does better financial performance mean India has surpassed China in solar manufacturing? Absolutely not.
The Altman Z-Score measures financial indicators such as working capital, profitability, leverage, retained earnings and market valuation.
It is useful for evaluating corporate financial risks, but it does not measure a country's overall industrial competitiveness.
It cannot tell us:
A financially healthy company is not necessarily a technologically advanced manufacturer.
Likewise, a company suffering financial losses does not automatically lose its manufacturing advantages.
Using financial scores to declare one country's solar industry superior to another is simply comparing two different things.
One of the biggest drivers behind India's solar manufacturing expansion is government policy.
The Approved List of Models and Manufacturers (ALMM) has created a protected domestic market for eligible Indian module manufacturers, particularly in government-supported projects and other covered segments.
This has generated several advantages:
There is nothing wrong with government support. China also used industrial policies to develop its solar manufacturing ecosystem.
However, there is a fundamental difference between expanding module production capacity and building a complete, competitive solar manufacturing industry.
India has made significant progress in module manufacturing, but its upstream supply chain remains a major weakness.
Its manufacturing ecosystem still faces substantial gaps in:
India can rapidly increase module assembly capacity, but that does not mean it has achieved the same level of supply chain independence as China.
If manufacturers still depend heavily on imported upstream materials and components, how can we describe the industry as fully self-sufficient?
Manufacturing capacity is not the same as manufacturing independence.
The biggest problem facing China's solar industry over recent years has been excessive capacity expansion, oversupply and aggressive price competition.
The collapse in polysilicon prices from RMB 235/kg in February 2023 to RMB 64/kg in July 2023, as mentioned in the PV Tech report, illustrates how dramatically market conditions changed.
Manufacturers invested heavily in expanding capacity during the industry's growth phase. When supply began exceeding demand, prices fell sharply and profit margins were squeezed.
Some manufacturers have suffered substantial losses.
However, this is fundamentally a problem of industrial overcapacity and profitability, not necessarily a loss of technological or manufacturing competitiveness.
China still maintains an overwhelming position across the major stages of the global solar supply chain.
According to IEA industry assessments, China accounts for approximately:
These figures demonstrate the enormous difference in industrial depth between the two countries.
China's solar industry is facing a profitability crisis, but its manufacturing ecosystem remains exceptionally powerful.
In fact, one could argue that China's biggest problem is not insufficient manufacturing capability, but excessive manufacturing capacity.
An interesting point in the PV Tech report is its reference to Indian manufacturers accessing higher prices in the United States.
This deserves further examination.
Some Indian manufacturers have benefited from favorable market conditions, including:
These factors have contributed to stronger revenues and profit margins.
However, these advantages are not necessarily permanent.
What happens if US trade policies change?
What happens if US domestic manufacturing capacity expands further?
What happens if trade restrictions and pricing advantages become less favorable?
Can Indian manufacturers maintain their current profit margins under fully competitive international market conditions?
These are important questions that financial score comparisons alone cannot answer.
If we want to evaluate the real competitiveness of the Chinese and Indian solar industries, we should compare their industrial capabilities rather than simply comparing their financial performance.
| Key indicator | China | India |
|---|---|---|
| Global manufacturing scale | Dominant | Rapidly expanding |
| Upstream supply chain | Highly integrated | Significant gaps |
| Silicon wafer production | Global leader | Limited capacity |
| Solar cell technology | Advanced manufacturing ecosystem | Developing rapidly |
| Large-scale manufacturing | Highly mature | Expanding |
| Manufacturing cost competitiveness | Strong structural advantages | Still developing |
| Domestic market protection | More competitive market environment | Strong government support |
| Corporate profitability | Under significant pressure | Improving for some manufacturers |
India is undoubtedly becoming an important player in the global solar industry.
However, growing quickly does not mean it has already reached China's industrial level.
There is a substantial difference between building manufacturing capacity and establishing a complete, globally competitive manufacturing ecosystem.
There are several strategic reasons.
First, national industrial ambitions.
India wants to position itself as a global manufacturing hub. Solar PV, batteries and semiconductors are important parts of this strategy.
Second, attracting international investment.
As the US and Europe seek to diversify their supply chains away from China, India has an opportunity to attract foreign investment and international manufacturing projects.
Third, highlighting favorable performance indicators.
When Chinese manufacturers are reporting losses while Indian manufacturers are improving their financial positions, Indian companies naturally have an incentive to emphasize these achievements.
However, if the comparison shifts to wafer production, upstream materials, global supply chain share, manufacturing technology and actual production volumes, the picture becomes very different.
Fourth, confusing growth rates with absolute industrial strength.
India's solar manufacturing industry is growing rapidly, but a high growth rate does not automatically translate into global leadership.
Looking at the next five to ten years, the competition between China and India will be worth watching.
China's solar industry faces a serious challenge: restoring profitability, reducing excess capacity and moving away from destructive price competition.
India's challenge is different: transforming its rapidly expanding module manufacturing sector into a genuinely integrated and technologically competitive solar supply chain.
These are two very different stages of industrial development.
India deserves recognition for its progress. Its domestic market, government policies and international investment opportunities will continue to support manufacturing growth.
But claiming that India has already surpassed China in solar manufacturing is not supported by the broader industrial evidence.
China is trying to recover profitability from an industry with enormous manufacturing capacity and a highly integrated supply chain. India is still working to transform policy-supported manufacturing expansion into genuine industrial independence.
A higher Altman Z-Score may indicate healthier corporate finances.
It does not make a country the world's leading solar manufacturing power.
And that distinction matters.
Industry Perspective: Solar PV Manufacturing, Global Supply Chains and Market Competitiveness.